Trademark Dilution
Dilution occurs through either tarnishment or blurring.
Blurring occurs when the trademark is weakened because it is associated
with other users' products and or services. Dilution by blurring is
association arising from the similarity between a mark or trade name
and a famous mark that impairs the distinctness of the famous mark.
As an easier way to consider blurring, some describe trademark
blurring as “blunting” the capacity of a famous mark to cut through
the clutter of the marketplace. For example, making the Nike "Swoosh"
less distinguishable.
Dilution by tarnishment occurs when a famous mark is improperly
associated with an inferior or offensive product or service.
Dilution by tarnishment is association arising from the similarity
between a mark or trade name and a famous mark that harms the
reputation of the famous mark. Frequently, courts have found
such negative connotations in situations where a mark was used
in the context of drugs, nudity, and sex.
A dilution cause of action does not come without its requirements.
First, the trademark owner must show actual dilution, not just a
likelihood of dilution. Second, the trademark that is allegedly
being diluted must be famous. A mark is famous if it is widely
recognized by the general consuming public in the United States
as a designation of source of the goods or service of the mark's
owner. In determining whether a mark possesses the necessary
degree of recognition, all relevant factors are considered, including:
- The duration, extent, and geographic reach of advertising
and publicity of the mark, whether advertised or publicized
by the owner or third parties.
- The amount, volume, and geographic extent of
sales of goods or services offered under the mark.
- The extent of actual recognition of the mark.
- Whether the mark is registered with the United
States Patent and Trademark Office
For dilution by blurring, a court may consider all relevant factors, including:
- The degree of similarity between the mark or trade name and the famous mark.
- The degree of inherent or acquired distinctiveness of the famous mark.
- The extent to which the owner of the famous mark is engaging in
substantially exclusive use of the mark.
- The degree of recognition of the famous mark.
- Whether the user of the mark or trade name intended to create an
association with the famous mark.
- Any actual association between the mark or trade name and the famous mark.
For dilution by tarnishment, there are no specific factors,
but rather a case by case analysis of any negative connotations as mentioned above.
Thus, trademark dilution claims, require the examination
of many factors and are highly complex. If you believe someone is
diluting your mark, you should contact us.
|